[BACK]

Executive Summary

Background

§            This rapid assessment is supported by the East Asia Pacific Region NGO Working Group on the World Bank.  The NGO Forum on Cambodia takes the position that national strategic planning in Cambodia be viewed as one activity and that all International Financial Institutions who are involved – World Bank, International Monetary Fund and Asian Development Bank – must be included in the analysis.

§            Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSP) are a new requirement from the World Bank and the IMF for countries wishing to access concessional loans.  They intend that a participatory planning process will create support for national policies, from donors and from governments and societies in the borrowing country.

Analysis

§            Competing demands of ADB and World Bank led Royal Government to initiate a phased process (I-PRSP then SEDP II then full PRSP).  Instead of a long process with several months for each phase (problem analysis; creative exploration of strategic options; decisions and costings) each step has been compressed and repeated. 

§            As a result, at this stage in the process very few within or outside government are familiar with the content of the plans, nor what they aim to achieve.  Thus far, no element of the process could legitimately be called 'participatory'.

§            Content also appears to have suffered, with little sense so far in documents of what strategic choices have been made or for what reasons

§            Much technical assistance has been 'substitution' rather than 'capacity-building'

Recommendations

Royal Government of Cambodia

§            Have one strategic plan only (five year).  Meet with the World Bank and the ADB to request better donor coordination in support of this one strategic plan.

§            In order to get broader engagement and support, take more time to advertise the strategic plan, its purpose and the process for making it.

§            Ensure there are strong links from strategic planning to multi-year and annual budgeting and from budgeting to expenditure.  

Non-Governmental Organisations

§            Mobilise human resources (several people, full-time) firstly to provide assistance to the Royal Government for strategic planning and poverty monitoring, and secondly to build up a level of knowledge and capability within the NGO sector to engage constructively in policy dialogue.

§            Facilitate public policy dialogue between poor people and policy-makers (eg between farmers in the North-West and national officials who are pro-regional integration)

World Bank/Asian Development Bank/International Monetary Fund

§            Significantly improve coordination – so no more separate missions and separate consultants for strategic planning.

§            Create more 'space' for national ownership of national policies and plans.